So This is the New Coors

« Some Duncan Thoughts | Main | Tough Loss »

The Cardinals managed six hits in two games at Coors and they're 1 and 1. Part of that is Carpenter and the Rockies pitching of course and maybe there's some bad hitting there too. However there were a couple of at-bats on Tuesday where the ball just didn't seem to carry the way it used to. Actually the ball didn't seem to carry the way it does at Busch III. While it's well-documented that the humidor is having this kind of effect, it's a little different seeing it with your own eyes when your own team is playing.

My hours were a little messed-up from the Dodgers series, so I didn't see the Monday game against the Rockies on TV. It was just as well, I suppose. The best positive spin on Reyes's progress is that he's being remade into a major league pitcher, that he's a work in progress. Unfortunately in my own personal hell, I'm imagining LaRussa trying to teach Reyes how to sing "The rains in Spain fall mainly in the plains." If this keeps up, then I may need to skip another Reyes start and watch the original Rex Harrison/Audrey Hepburn version instead.

Tuesday's game had all kinds of plotlines. Carpenter's a great pitcher and Pujols did what needed to be done again. Isringhausen finished it his way and Rolen had another defensive gem, a ridiculous throw from the muck. The Rockies broadcast crew brought up Rolen's Hall of Fame case, and I'd like to check that out. But what got my attention was Clint Barmes extending his hitting streak to 13 games. As you may recall, a couple of weeks ago Barmes was the only major league regular with a worse OPS than Yadier Molina. ESPN.com's sortable stats do in fact show that Molina's 581 OPS is dead last among qualified batters, trailing Ronny Cedeno of the Cubs by about 15 points at this writing.

So here's the question I had for the Lahman database: How have young players with a 400 AB season with a sub-600 OPS fared historically? By young, I mean under the age of 24 and I'm only looking at player since WWII. I've compiled a list of such players, and it's an eye-opening stroll down memory lane:

Player Age Season OPS Career OPS Development
Gair Allie 22 562 562 0
Rick Auerbach 22 546 572 26
John Bateman 22 583 621 38
Ed Brinkman 23 508 580 72
Jack Brohamer 22 565 633 68
Mike Caruso 22 577 641 64
Mike Champion 22 557 564 7
Julio Cruz 23 588 620 32
Mariano Duncan 23 589 688 99
Kevin Elster 23 594 677 83
Tim Foli 23 591 593 2
Wayne Garrett 21 558 691 133
Ozzie Guillen 22 576 626 50
Cristian Guzman 21 543 671 128
Jack Heidemann 20 557 532 -25
Enzo Hernandez 22 545 550 5
Glenn Hoffman 23 573 623 50
Paul Householder 23 592 667 75
Cesar Izturis 23 597 633 36
Sonny Jackson 22 568 611 43
Tim Johnson 23 502 539 37
Hal Lanier 23 546 529 -17
Roy McMillan 23 591 635 44
Roger Metzger 23 593 584 -9
Ken Reitz 22 589 649 60
Billy Ripken 23 518 612 94
Dave Roberts 21 595 644 49
Brooks Robinson 21 597 723 126
Aurelio Rodriguez 21 579 626 47
Ramon Santiago 23 576 600 24
Dick Schofield 21 527 624 97
Derrel Thomas 22 559 649 90
Hector Torres 22 510 542 32
Mike Tyson 23 577 612 35
Del Unser 23 560 677 117
Curtis Wilkerson 23 561 591 30
Robin Yount 20 593 772 179
AVERAGE 22 566 621 55

I didn't realize Brooks Robinson was that un-accomplished as a hitter, even adjusting for era. I also didn't realize Reitz was that bad. Back to Molina, it's not that promising, but what really got my attention is that there's only one catcher on that list, John Bateman. Bateman played for the 1963 Houston Colt .45s, a bad club only in its second year. Now I assume Yadier will improve as a hitter, maybe soon enough to make this list moot, but he still is an odd duck. What the Cardinals have done and are doing with him is unique and it's remarkable that they're doing it while competing for pennants.

Posted by Rob at July 26, 2006 01:18 AM
TrackBacks (Trackback URL: http://www.thebirdwatch.com/mt/bw-tb.pl/1140)