Open Thread: He's Already Pulled Over, He Can't Pull Over Any More

« Death, Taxes, And... | Main | 2007 Projections: Reyes of Sunshine »

tony.JPG

So, yeah, everyone's heard about it by now. And plenty of people, both inside and outside of Cardinal Nation have put in their two cents on the matter. But I implore you, the loyal readers of The Birdwatch: what do you think?

My opinion: hell yeah, he made a mistake. Should he be punished? Yes, and the state of Florida will take care of that. Should we judge him for this mistake? No. Why? He's human. People make mistakes - and celebrity or not, the decent thing to do is to forgive. It's obvious Tony is an upstanding guy. He has a clean record into his 60s, for God's sakes - what percentage of the population can say that? He knows he screwed up. I'd be willing to wager just about anything that he doesn't do it again, because he's just that kind of guy. He hates to fail his team on the field, and when he does he works his ass off to make up for it. What makes you think he wouldn't do the same in a situation like this? I say don't worry, Tony - here at The Birdwatch, we've (or at least I've) got your back.

UPDATE: Bill McClellan has a nice article on the topic as well.

And amazingly enough, that isn't the only Cardinal-related controversy of the week. Yikes. It's tough being on top.

Program note: Reyes and Wainwright projections to come... this weekend!

Posted by MO Boiler at March 23, 2007 04:41 PM
TrackBacks (Trackback URL: http://www.thebirdwatch.com/mt/bw-tb.pl/1203)

I agree. He's a human being who has earned himself a huge amount of slack here. Drunk driving is a big deal, but from the sounds of it he had a few too many glasses of wine at dinner and is...well becoming an old guy. It's not like he was going ninety and swerving all over the road with a hooker in the car. Sounds like a pooped old guy who had 1 too many after a hard day's work who couldn't keep his eyes open. Also, I understand his blood alcohol level wouldn't even be considered over the limit in most states.

He's obviously very sorry and quite humiliated and the right thing to do is applaud like crazy for him opening day. (But according to Jose what's his face at the Houston Chron, that would make me a 'moron'.)

Posted by: Erik at March 25, 2007 12:17 AM